Didn't like much of their song picks. In order here's how I rated them.
1. Bo
2. Vonzell
3. Anthony
4. Carrie
5. Constantine
6. Scott
I agree with Simon on Constantine, he crossed over to the dark side and trying to go back just didn't do it. Yeah he may be a Rocker but I think he found a niche with the other music. I hated the song and think he was off key a lot.
Scott - It was bad, off key almost as much as Constantine. Difference is that Constantine has his looks and stage presence on his side.
Carrie, didn't like the song, never heard if before but she did it well.
Anthony fabulous, maybe better than Vonzell I actually think Vonzell and Anthony were tied but I had to put one above the other. The only thing I see with Anthony is that we already have a Clay and don't need another one.
Vonzell. Great
Bo - Yep Great as well.
Really Bo, Vonzell and Anthony in my opinion are safe and equal in their performances at the top.
The first column is my personal estimation of how they rate, American Idol-wise, regardless of their performance tonight. The second column represents a rating based on the personal enjoyment of their performance tonight by myself & Mrs. AZIdolFan.
Carrie 1 - 7
Vonzell 2 - 9
Anthony 3 - 10
Constantine 4 - 1
Scott 5 - 5
Bo 6 - 0
My prediction is that Scott will being singing his song again tomorrow night.
Anthony: He was the only one who did not go off pitch once. That was enough for me to vote for him. And his voice was strong and pleasant. I don't know what all the hullaballoo is about his masculinity...I thought he was handsome.
Constantine: Oh boyee. I love that song, I sing it on long and hard bicycle rides to keep me going. But this version. Blech. He was trying to copy the original style and his voice was not raspy enough or deep enough. And the worst part is that his pitch was completely off the entire time. I don't care how much you run around the stage and swagger with a microphone, the boy cain't sang.
Scott: Pitch off. Blech. The man needs to discover his diaghragm...reach down into that big ole belly and discover the art of singing from your diaghragm.
Otherwise his voice sounds like a whisper and he has no support for the high notes.
Did anyone notice how Secrest made comments about girls digging Anthony and Constantine, but skipped poor ole Scott?
IMO...I think Scott is on his way home tomorrow...
He's been in the bottom three for weeks now...and I think tomorrow is his time. He was just horrible.
Bo was awesome!
Constantine...I didnt like it, but he will not be going home, as I think Scott will save him from that.
Carrie...not for me tonight...not at all.
Vonzell...she was really good!
Anthony...I think this guy has an amazing voice, but I agree with Ron...his being so close to Clay will hurt him...though being in the top five (granted Scott leaves tomorrow) isnt a shabby place to be!
Of course thats just my opinion....I could be wrong. (Dennis Miller)
"You might be the toughest little whacker. . .but in my world, you're about as worrisome as a cloudy day." (Dutch Dooley)
1. Bo Bice He is the one to beat an awesome performance
2. Vonzell, She is getting stronger each week
3. Anthony. Very good and coming along well. He alas is another Clay and that hurts him
4. Constantine- Didn't like song or him much tonight But don't hink he will be in bottom three . too many kiddies love him
5. Carrie- I just didn't like her tonight or any night. Over rated and blew it tonight. Then in the past two weeks forgets words? Comeon she will be in the bottom three
6. Scott. Yuk Enough already Please get him out of there, I am tired of feeling sorry for him.
Bottom Three Scott, Carrie, Anthony
Thats the Way I see it. Delta
aka deltacent aka deltater
Life may not be the party I had hoped for.......
But while I'm here I might just as well listen to the music and dance..
I don't think Anthony, based on last night performance, will be in the bottom 3. But I just don't see him winning. I think the winner will either be Bo or Vonzell.
I guess you heard Simon tell Scott to start packing his suitcase last night. I hate that, as I've stated so many times! He can rip his performance, but he has no business suggesting to the voters that he should be eliminated!
That said in spite of the fact that I want to see Scott leave. Well...actually, there's someone else I'd much rather see go, but since that ain't gonna happen, I hope it's Scott, with his nasty demeanor.
Simon's pulling that stunt once again still irks me. You can be sure it'll be Scott tonight. It usually seems to work for Simon.
AZIdolfan said this in post #12 : Simon's pulling that stunt once again still irks me. You can be sure it'll be Scott tonight. It usually seems to work for Simon.
I agree that its not right for Simon to do that....but lets be honest...even if Simon hadnt of said that, chances are that Scott would be leaving anyhow...
He has been in the bottom for the past three or so weeks...so its fair to say that his time was coming anyhow...
I dont think people expected anyone to be leaving tonight but Scott.
Of course thats just my opinion....I could be wrong. (Dennis Miller)
"You might be the toughest little whacker. . .but in my world, you're about as worrisome as a cloudy day." (Dutch Dooley)
I agree that its not right for Simon to do that....but lets be honest...even if Simon hadnt of said that, chances are that Scott would be leaving anyhow...
He has been in the bottom for the past three or so weeks...so its fair to say that his time was coming anyhow...
I dont think people expected anyone to be leaving tonight but Scott.
Based on performances it should be Constantine going home tonight. I believe that may have been the worst American Idol performance of all time. There was absolutely nothing redeeming about it.
Carrie was pretty awful as well in my opinion.
The only good performances last night were in order - Anthony, Vonzell and Bo. I don't particularly care for Anthony but last night he gave the best performance of the group.
04-27-2005 02:23 AM
