I'm not saying any of that that is just my opinion. Everyone is entitled to their own opinion. I'm not saying anythin perverted. it only means in my opinion she sucks. That's what i ment by blows. lol. u all thought I was talking sick or something. I'm friggin 11 ppl. EEwWW.lol
Singer_chick
the fantasia thread was closed because of the flaming in there. It is fine to have an opinion, but do try to use non-flaming language to get your point across.
Look ppl i'm not trying to be racis what i said had nothing racis nor perverted in it. I simply said i don't like Fantasia in my opinion. When i say someone blows i don't mean anything close to race nor perverted. In my opinion it simply means someone or something sucks in my opinion. Please do not take that ofencively. It means something sucks in my opinion. i'm friggin 11 ppl.
Singer Chick, on many boards if you say that you do not like Fantasia, people cry "hater". Tell them why you do not like her voice, and I am pretty sure that the "hater" speak will stop.
I'm with you singer_chick....everyone always thinks I hate blacks just because I don't like Fantasia....or because I like Diana over her.....I don't like Fantasia's voice bottom line...
I love Luke Schenscher! I miss David Greene! *Go Georgia Tech*
2-10-05~is a day that will forever live on in history as the day I saw, met and Ryan Cabrera gave me a high 5! The show was great and Ryan is the funniest man alive! I love u, Mr. Cabrera!
we know you're not a racist, singer chick. i should have been more clear as to why i closed the thread. i was in one of my 'moods'. fuscia is correct, the thread was closed because of the flaming.
it's clear you're no fan of fantasia. neither am i. did you have a favorite this year?
I love Luke Schenscher! I miss David Greene! *Go Georgia Tech*
2-10-05~is a day that will forever live on in history as the day I saw, met and Ryan Cabrera gave me a high 5! The show was great and Ryan is the funniest man alive! I love u, Mr. Cabrera!
fuscia said this in post #5 : Singer Chick, on many boards if you say that you do not like Fantasia, people cry "hater". Tell them why you do not like her voice, and I am pretty sure that the "hater" speak will stop.
{Sigh} You might as well tell Singer Chick to give up. I, and others, have experienced some of the same medicine ourselves. If you state in this forum that you dislike Fantasia's voice (or anything else about her), you are a "racist" in some people's eyes. Of course, if you said the same thing about Diana, you wouldn't hear a peep from those same people!
Having said that, let me now interject something new, based on an event yesterday. Did anyone see Fantasia sing the national anthem at the baseball All-Star Game? This morning, on Jim Bohannon's nationally syndicated radio show, his sports reporter, Tony Roberts, complained about the "worst rendition of the Star Spangled Banner he had ever heard (or some such words-I may not be quoting him verbatim). I have to say that my wife and I also thought it was God-awful! She blew the words ("lamparts" instead of "ramparts", for example), her pitch was terrible and her attempt to put her own touch to it came across as the worst national anthem rendition I have heard in my entire life. She also did her patented "dip. dip. dip" routine while singing - totally inappropriate for a national anthem performance.
Did anyone see Clay Aiken sing the anthem on July 4th at the PBS "Capitol Fourth" presentation? There is a singer! I haven't heard Diana's version sung at the Atlanta Braves game, but I'd bet everything I have it was head & shoulders better than Fantasia's.
The "judges" selected the wrong American Idol, sorry. And for those who haven't read everything that's been said here, yes, the "judges" did select the Idol. They did so by influencing the voters and by manipulating the show to favor Fantasia, for their own personal, financial reward. That's my humble opinion, and I stand by it!
AZidolfan, I agree with you and now that you spoke...I'm going too....
This morning on our radio...they played Fantasia singing the national anthem...and I didn't have to wait for them to say it was bad before I thought it.....I never liked Fantasia's voice...and I was upset by the way she kinda hurt our national anthem....
I didn't hear Diana sing the natural anthem, at the Braves Game, on July 4th, but I have heard her sing it before at my school (we live in the same county) and she's really good at it.
Clay sounded great but there is only one Clay Aiken. He has a voice that is unbelievable and I think he is the best thing to have come from Idol.
I don't agree with the "judges"...Fantasia wasn't the best singer this season and although I like Diana...I think Latoya had the best voice this season....I had always hoped it would of come down to Diana vs. Latoya...that would of been a showdown to see....
I love Luke Schenscher! I miss David Greene! *Go Georgia Tech*
2-10-05~is a day that will forever live on in history as the day I saw, met and Ryan Cabrera gave me a high 5! The show was great and Ryan is the funniest man alive! I love u, Mr. Cabrera!
OK, I see the problem! Of course you're not a racist sweetie! However, a problem occure when one attempts to IMPOSE his/her opinion upon others. In order to prevent such a problem-just humblhy state your opinion- and keep going. In the end - what difference does ones opinion REALLY make in these girls' lives? You nor I get to go home with either one of their pay checks. I still have my Visa bill, and you have yours. Diana nor Fantasia have taken on that responsibility. So what difference does our opinion really make in the WHOLE scheme of things? I will still buy who I want to buy and you will do the same.
Now, here is my opinion - I hear Fantasia totally differently. To me, she sang the words correctly. She just happens to have a Southern twang that disguises her words so one can't quit understand them (and I totally hate the twang cause I'm a Cali girl) but I love her voice and she has all the persoanlity in the world. And as far as her patented "dip.dip.dip."...Is it really appropriate to mention that and not mention Clay's "wink, wink, wink" he does with his big blue eyes all of time? Just thought I might mention that....Or is it a "blink, blink,blink?
I LOVE Clay's voice. I believe that Clay should have won last year. In MY OPINION, based on all around skill and personality Clay should have won last year and the correct person won this year. They both have a tremendous amount of talent, skill, and personality that is displayed in every public apperance. That is my opinion.
P.S. If we have a bunch of fools in Florida that can SELECT a President of the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA - why can't Simon Cowell select an American Idol? (although I don't believe he did)
spelmangrad said this in post #11 :
If we have a bunch of fools in Florida that can SELECT a President of the UNITED STATES OF AMERICA - why can't Simon Cowell select an American Idol? (although I don't believe he did)
Thanks for your opinion, most of which I take exception to (except for some of the "P.S" portion). You're correct. There's not a whole lot of difference between a candidate for President being "selected" by a biased Supreme Court and an "American Idol" being "selected" by a biased group of judges.
spelmangrad....I just want to say THANKS for being so nice...with that post...
~the whole clay thing~
I think that Clay should of won 2nd season because he was great and he won like almost everyone over....his voice is just so great....he is so....alright if you couldn't already tell...I am like Clay's biggest fan...sorry..ok so I'll move on from him....but their is only one Clay Aiken....no one in my opinion will ever be as good as Clay
~Fantasia and Diana~
I think over all...both girls had talent....I just like Diana's better. I mean in the end, it doesn't matter because the season went the way it did...and we can't change it now.....no matter what both girls are going to have a career on their hands. I wish both of them luck...
I have to be real here, I don't like Fantasia's voice but "I believe" was so her song.....Diana although she sung it well...was a little out of her game....Dreams (her single) was more her song.....
no matter what though, I am always going to be cheering for the hometown girl.....
I love Luke Schenscher! I miss David Greene! *Go Georgia Tech*
2-10-05~is a day that will forever live on in history as the day I saw, met and Ryan Cabrera gave me a high 5! The show was great and Ryan is the funniest man alive! I love u, Mr. Cabrera!
hot4johnstevens said this in post #13 : no one in my opinion will ever be as good as Clay
I could not agree more with you. Clay has been the best performer in the first three seasons, by leaps and bounds! No one even comes close to him.
As a matter of interest, he is giving concerts around the country. Here are some ticket agencies' ticket prices for his show scheduled in Atlantic City - in many cases, over $800 PER TICKET! Check out all the other ticket brokers. They're in similar price ranges.
yea I'm upset because Clay isn't coming back to Atlanta...and yea...I think Clay is the best thing to happen to American Idol and I wish he won but maybe it worked out for the better that he didn't....
I love Luke Schenscher! I miss David Greene! *Go Georgia Tech*
2-10-05~is a day that will forever live on in history as the day I saw, met and Ryan Cabrera gave me a high 5! The show was great and Ryan is the funniest man alive! I love u, Mr. Cabrera!
07-12-2004 07:50 PM
