Balanced & Reasoned
Registered: Apr 2004
Local time: 12:44 PM
For my money, I would prefer that they not sing songs that were sung by finalists from previous seasons, at least until they get down to the final eight or ten. Then they should be permitted to sing anything that they think would further their chances to win.
What I have a problem with is the totally untalented goofballs that appear in the early going and sing songs that Kelly, Ruben or Clay sang, trying to ride on their coattails. They then proceed to stain any lasting memory of how well those talented people performed those same songs.