Shadow Stalker said this in post #41 : that whole sword reforged thing happend in FOTR (book) so it better be a flash back..other wise its out of place...oh well...a minor detail i suppose.
No, I agree with you. It was not done at that point in time. It happened before they set out from Rivendell. I suppose those of us who are really Tolkien geeks just get a little miffed at some of the things.
yeah.....the minor details have a tendency to stack up though...not that i'm dissapointed with the movies, i absolutely love them. and i think that if he had unlimited showing time, PJ would have put in those minor details.