Who in the top 12 would you replace and with whom?

Fame Forum

There are several that I wish would have made it into the top 12 that didn't like Mackenzie, Ryan, Michelle, Johannes and Sean.

If it were up to me they would have made it to the top 12 instead of (and nobody freak out or get upset or anything, it's just my opinion ) Jamie, Brandon, Raymond, Garry and Serena...

Guess in general I tend to lean toward the dancers over the vocalists...

Your opinion please?

In my opinion, this topic borders on being mean...

Saying who you think should be in the top 12 is great, because it is a positive thing to say about those people, but naming the contestants that you don't think deserve their position in the top 12... that's just mean. Those people worked really hard, and if the judges think they're good enough, who are we to say they shouldn't be there?

plus, I'm sure that if Jamie, Brandon, Raymond, Garry or Serena saw this post, it'd sadden them. They're still people who have feelings... I know seeing them on TV makes us forget that sometimes.

I'm glad to see that you consider Brandon a vocalist!! I guess that does mean that you like his voice! But as I have said before(as his dance teacher) - he is a Dancer! Brandon is technically trained and takes hours of classes EVERY DAY (even before Fame) including advanced ballet classes! He is actually one of the strongest dancers in the group! He just looks like a kid who can hip hop and move well but so far he hasnt had alot of camera time. I certainly dont want to sound like a certain other supporter on here but i know with a little more exposure to the camera you all will agree that he has it all!

shelmibell, Well, I said in *general* I prefer the dancers to the singers...

Chipmunk, I have said before though I definitely think ALL of the top 24 are very talented! They wouldn't be there if they weren't! So I give them all the respect I think they're due for making it that far...

But if this show is about narrowing it down to 12 and then to 1, what is wrong with stating your preferences for the top 12?

Get used to it, because before this show is over you'll be seeing a lot of people stating such opinions on this board...

There is nothing wrong with stating opinions at all - That is what makes this interesting!! All I was doing was adding a little info about Brandon for all to think about! After all, we will be the ones voting for the winner and if I didnt add what I felt you all needed to hear about Brandon i would be doing him a disservice. I love hearing what other people are interested in. Alot of comments have made ME look at some of the other performers a little closer too! No offense taken - keep sharing!!

shelmibelle, thanks for the info about Brandon! I'll watch for his dancing more...

And believe me, it was hard for me to decide on who I would "drop" in favor of my favorite contestants! Esp. Garry & Serena!

I really wish that Ryan would have made it........it makes me cry at night....... I stopped watching it after his performence and the next day, I asked my mom if Ryan had made it and she 'No'. I went back in my room,turned on the radio, and screamed intoa pillow for a very long time. Now I am KILLING my friends.They say I talk 'bout Ryan to much........... I don't think I do........

ryan ryan ryan ryan ryan ryan ryan ryan ryan ryan ryan ryan :

Ryanfreak, do you know Ryan personally?