Who should be the American Idol?

American Idol: Season 5 Forum

Vote and post who you will vote for on Tuesday to be the next American Idol.

So we are down to the last week of American Idol. The season has flown by.

I want to personally thank all who have participated in our American Idol forum this year. The recaps and reviews were especially good this year. I looked forward to reading the reviews each week.

The great thing about INReview is that we can have different opinions without it becoming a flame war like the American Idol board is all the time. So thank you to all for being here, and I hope each of you will be here next year for AI 6.

Please look around our forums. INReview is a place that is growing and changing. There are plenty of forums to keep us busy until the next Idol season.



and WOOOO! I'll be voting for Taylor until the time slot is over.

I want to second that... Sherry and I worked hard on the AI forum this year, more than ever before. Thank you all for participating, no matter how little, or big. Reading the reviews, each week, has been such a highlight for me. Now, I can't wait until next season, just to start this all over again!

I won't be voting... but, I don't care who wins. They are both winners, in my eyes, making the top two. They will both have albums. So, it doesn't matter.

I didn't even watch tonight so I don't care who wins either, I guess.

Personally, after hearing Kat do, Somewhere Over The Rainbow, just now, I definately think that she has the chops, and would like to see her win! But, like I've been saying, I think that Taylor will take the win.

Excellent work this year Fuscia / Lawless on the forum... lotta fun this season.

I voted for Taylor despite Katherine's potential for technically being a superior singer. What Taylor posseses is a uniqueness factor that doesn't come along very often. His ability to utilize that trait in his performances greatly impacts his longevity and success.

For that reason, I would be surprised if Katharine won (though I was pushing for her and Chris to be in the finale together).

I actually enjoyed Kat's first two songs. I like her cover of Black Horse and the Cherry Tree better than Turnstalls.


Marc, I think you summed up very well why Taylor most likely will win it. No one can deny that Katharine has a fantastic voice, but Taylor is unique, and he knows who he is as a musician.

Taylor should win this thing.

I'm still ticked over Chris and Elliott, and I think Kat is a good singer and looks the part but she is lacking something.

GO TAY!