Who's going home this week PICK NOW!

American Idol: Season 5 Forum

Of course we have

Taylor

Katharine

Elliot

I woiuld have to say that 95% of the members picked Taylor and Katharine in their top 4. Elliot was picked by less than half.

I picked Elliot because I just don't think he has the voice. If he can get away from the vibrato then maybe but I don't think he can. A good singing coach is in order to help him with that vibrato think. It really annoys me.

Katharine however keeps throwing in those trills. Man cut it out, your getting better but I would like just for once hear you hold a note without trailing it with a trill. YUK!

Picking before the performance... based on inconsistancies, I would have to say, Katharine, hands down.

(PS... there is a thread up, with a poll, just for tonight's show. But, I like that we're doing a pre-poll, to see what people think.)

It's backlash week for all those infatuated with Daughtry, so Katharine is gone.

My votes would have nothing to do with backlash. It's about who is performing, each week, in a more consistant way. Elliott has, and Kat hasn't. Doesn't mean that she can't sing.

But, if she doesn't go this week, I won't be surprised.