Simon predicts a Chris/Taylor finale - American Idol: Season 5

Simon predicts a Chris/Taylor finale

American Idol: Season 5 Forum

Pages:  1Original Forum    Popular Forums    Search

Posted by: fuscia

NEW YORK — This season's "American Idol" finale will be all about the guys - recalling Ruben Studdard's battle against Clay Aiken three years ago.

At least that's the assessment of "Idol" judge Simon Cowell as the competition heads into the homestretch, with only four contestants (three of them guys) remaining as pop-star wannabes.

"If I had to put money on it, I think it will be between Chris [Daughtry] and Taylor [Hicks]," Cowell said on yesterday's "Good Morning America."

His words carry a lot of weight, since it's believed that many "Idol" fans vote on who to eliminate from the show each week based on Cowell's comments on the Tuesday-night sing-off show.

If Cowell turns out to be prophetic, and Daughtry and Hicks are the two left standing on the May 24 "Idol" finale, it will mirror the epic finale from three seasons back.

In May 2003, the beefy, jersey-wearing Studdard - dubbed "The Velvet Teddy Bear" - was up against Aiken, the red-headed country boy from North Carolina. Going into the finale, it was anyone's guess who'd pull off the victory.

When the dust cleared, Studdard emerged victorious - although, since then, Aiken has had the more successful recording career (and even has his own rabid following, the "Claymates").

Still, during his appearance on yesterday's "GMA," Cowell didn't rule out a surprising victory by the one remaining female "Idol" contestant: Katharine McPhee.

Many have considered McPhee the odds-on favorite to win since the new season kicked off last winter.

"You can't rule out Katharine because she's just getting better and better," Cowell said.

Speaking after Wednesday night's show, in which Paris Bennett was eliminated, Cowell also said next week's "Elvis Presley" theme will help Daughtry and Hicks, who both hail from the South (as did Presley).

(Daughtry's from North Carolina, Hicks is from Alabama.)

"It's going to be good for Chris, it's going to be good for Taylor," he told the local Fox affiliate.

"Elliot [Yamin] or Katharine - the two of them are vulnerable next week."

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Lawless

USA Today is predicting a Taylor/Katharine finale.


Star is predicting Taylor as the winner of AI5.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: fuscia

I see no way that Kat is going to the final. It will be a Chris/Taylor final, and I have no clue who will win. It will be a close one.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Lawless

It's anyone's "game" at this point, in my opinion. I happen to like all four of the contestants (though, I do have my favorite... as if no one knew), and would love to see a career for them all.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: niwrad428

With who's left I think the final 2 should be Elliot and Chris.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: lickety_split

Simon also predicted that Paris will win AI.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Lawless

Simon says whatever he feels like, at that particular moment.

Reply To this Message

Pages:  1 Free Forums    Chat Forum

American Idol: Season 5 Forum: Simon predicts a Chris/Taylor finale

Forum Forum Forum