4/11/06 Who should be voted off the show tonight?

American Idol: Season 5 Forum

Who do you think should go after tonight's performance? Post your thoughts, your reviews, or whatever, in here. (Or, you can do your own review thread in our sub-forum "Member Recaps").

I can't wait to see it. There are supposed to be some good performances. Simon is an ass as usual, but I hear Taylor brought down the house. WOO!

Okay...Kellie was AWESOME tonite!!! She did good with that whole rocker chick thing...Way better then Paris TRIED to pull it off. Chris well...he is always good except not sure about last week's performance. Randi was right he should have done a bigger song...cuz he would have pulled it off. Taylor danced yet again like Elvis having a seizure but his vocals were good. Katharine was a little shouty, almost like she was screaming the song. I still think she did good. Bucky was okay...not my favorite but okay along with Elliot. Ace needs to go...along with Paris. Good vocals for Paris though I have to admit. Ace overall should go this week. Well I will look forward to your thoughts!!!

Love,
Ang

For my full review... look in Member Recaps.

Well, there was only two tonight that I didn't absolutely enjoy:

Bucky, and Ace. Katharine was good... but, she would have to be my choice for the third spot... with Ace going home.

Best tonight? Chris and Elliott. Both were AWESOME!!!

And, my vote for most improved this week: Kellie

My vote to go home went to Ace. Best without a doubt was Taylor. He brought down the house. Elliott was second for me. I have my review in member recaps.

Who is in danger tonight? This is the Dial Idol stats Bottom TWO being Bucky and Ace

1 Taylor Hicks 31.38 1.634 -
2 Kellie Pickler 27.912 1.675 -
3 Paris Bennett 26.298 1.694 -
4 Elliott Yamin 24.404 1.715 -
5 Katharine McPhee 22.55 1.736 -
6 Chris Daughtry 22.404 1.738 -
7 Bucky Covington 16.585 1.802 -
8 Ace Young 16.31 1.805

As long as it's Ace or Bucky tonight, I will be happy. Then again, if Paris or Kellie left, I wouldn't really cry. But, I just really want Ace and Bucky to leave the show.

If I can find the AT&T stats I'll post them.

Great! Would love to see what they were.

East Coast numbers- out of order

1. 3, 337, 840-Taylor
2. 1, 938, 400-Paris
3. 1, 666, 700-Kellie
4. 992 ,009 -Katharine
5. 1, 466 ,497-Elliot
6. 1, 409 ,700-Chris
7. 1, 452 ,616-Bucky
8. 966 ,667-Ace

Well, Ace and Katharine had low numbers in that one.
Katharine less than Ace though?

Kat is pretty and has a great voice, but she doesn't have the presence that the others do. Still, I think that Ace will go home.

I voted to boot off Ace. He dissed Queen.

I did not much care for the show last night. Not being a Queen fan I had to sit through eight people singing music that I would rather not hear. I think that Ace was the worst though, and his attitude was very rude toward that band. Was it me or did he make comments that would have been insulting to them?

Bucky....I've wanted him gone for weeks. Granted his performances give me a chance to do more worthwhile things but....it's time for him to make the grand exit out.