America's nationbuilding record is clear - Post-9/11 Era

America's nationbuilding record is clear

Post-9/11 Era Forum

Pages:  1Original Forum    Popular Forums    Search

Posted by: h@ts

quote:
The US track record for installing democracies ain't as great as the ideologues (and evangelical Republicans) would wish to believe. America has been involved in approximately 18 nation-building projects between its conquest of the Philippines in 1899 and the current occupations of Afghanistan and Iraq, and the overall record is not a pretty one.

The cases of unambiguous success-Germany, Japan, and South Korea-were all ones in which U.S. forces came and then stayed indefinitely. In the first two cases, we were not nation-building at all, but only re-legitimizing societies that had very powerful states. In all of the other cases, the U.S. either left nothing behind in terms of self-sustaining institutions, or else made things worse by creating, as in the case of Nicaragua, a modern army and police but no lasting rule of law."
Reply To this Message

Pages:  1 Free Forums    Chat Forum

Post-9/11 Era Forum: America's nationbuilding record is clear

Forum Forum Forum