The Phantom Of The Opera - Movies

The Phantom Of The Opera

Movies Forum

Pages:  1Original Forum    Popular Forums    Search

Posted by: AZIdolfan

My favorite musical show, one of the most beloved of all time and the second longest running show on Broadway (second only to "Cats") is coming to the big screen on December 22.

I didn't waste any time getting my copy of the soundtrack, released a few days ago, and it exceeds my expectations. Andrew Lloyd Webber is a genius. Joel Schumacher produced the film and it is expected to grab numerous awards.

I have seen the live show production five times, have tickets to see it once more next June, and expect to see the movie at least twice this month.

You can see the trailers, some images from the film and hear portions of the soundtrack at http://phantomthemovie.warnerbros.com/

I admit to being a "Phantom Phreak". I've always been a sucker for Broadway musicals, but this one has a certain magic that has no peer. If there are any other "Phreaks" out there, I'd love to discuss with you.

.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: schmiggens

I liked the POTO, not as much as Cats, but it was good. Who is in the movie?

Reply To this Message

Posted by: gaboman

I like it a lot more than Cats will definitely see this.

Cast:
Gerard Butler .... The Phantom
Emmy Rossum .... Christine
Patrick Wilson .... Raoul
Miranda Richardson .... Madame Giry
Minnie Driver .... Carlotta
Ciarán Hinds .... Firmin
Simon Callow .... Andre
Victor McGuire .... Piangi
Jennifer Ellison .... Meg Giry

Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

quote:
schmiggens said this in post #2 :
I liked the POTO, not as much as Cats, but it was good. Who is in the movie?


After an extensive search and years of delays, Gerard Butler was cast as the Phantom and Emmy Rossum as Christine. Emmy was only 17 years old when filming was begun. There was a lot of clamoring for the original Phantom, Michael Crawford, to play the Phantom, which lasted for years and, perhaps, delayed the actual production of the film. If you'd like to really see what has gone on behind the scenes over the years, as well as some great movie clips of the show, as well as the movie trailers, check out this site The Michael Crawford Phantom Movie Campaign. It used to provide access to a message board which evidenced the hordes of fans that were literally screaming for Michael Crawford to be selected for the role, but they have shut it down when it finally became known that he was not going to be given the part.

I, personally, have been agonizing for about five years now, waiting for this movie to finally be made! I have read about people who have seen the live stage production dozens of times and even one, if I recall, who saw it about 150 times. I'm only working on my sixth, so I have a long way to go!

Follow the link I posted above for a message board that will tell you almost anything you want to know about this show and how beloved it actually is! There's also another at http://www.phantomfans.net/
.
Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

quote:
gaboman said this in post #3 :
I like it a lot more than Cats will definitely see this.



Thanks for providing the cast details. I wasn't expecting too much when they bypassed Michael Crawford for the lead role because of his age, but I was pleasantly surprised on hearing the soundtrack. They did a great job - not perfect - but excellent, nonetheless. The filmography has to beat the limitations they have on stage props by a mile, so I'm expecting an extravaganza beyond belief, when I see the movie.

If you're like me and all the thousands of Phantom fans out there, once you have seen it, the music will get in your blood and you won't be able to get it out. Over the years, I must have listened to the original London Cast Album at least 200 times and several others, in addition to that.
Reply To this Message

Posted by: schmiggens

quote:
gaboman said this in post #3 :
Cast:
Gerard Butler .... The Phantom
Emmy Rossum .... Christine
Patrick Wilson .... Raoul
Miranda Richardson .... Madame Giry
Minnie Driver .... Carlotta
Ciarán Hinds .... Firmin
Simon Callow .... Andre
Victor McGuire .... Piangi
Jennifer Ellison .... Meg Giry


The only person I have heard of is Minnie Driver. I didn't know she could sing?
Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

quote:
schmiggens said this in post #6 :


The only person I have heard of is Minnie Driver. I didn't know she could sing?


Actually, she doesn't sing. Her singing part in the film is dubbed. However, I believe I did read somewhere that she sings the new song added for the movie that is performed during the closing credits.
Reply To this Message

Posted by: gaboman

hahaha, I didn't even notice Minnie Driver in the list. I guess what AZ said must be true, but I just read she actually has a CD coming out sometime soon..... if it's not already out

Reply To this Message

Posted by: schmiggens

Miming Minnie is a Phantom singer

For an actress, Minnie Driver packs a powerful soprano in the new movie version of Phantom of the Opera. But now the secret is out. It's not her voice.

Despite having launched a second career as a singer just three months ago, she mimes throughout the film in her role as the overthetop Latin prima donna, Carlotta.

And as Miss Driver lapped up the plaudits at the premiere earlier this week, the woman who provided the soaring tones that make her sound so impressive was suffering from a severe case of out of sight, out of mind.

Solihull singing teacher Margaret Preece was snubbed for Monday's lavish night out at London's Leicester Square.

"I wasn't invited," she said yesterday. "I was really disappointed. It would have been lovely to be there. I would have adored to walk down the red carpet. I'd even bought a dress. But sadly not. I suppose I'll have to pay to see it in my local cinema."

Mrs Preece, 43, played the part of Carlotta in the West End stage production of Phantom for four years and was delighted to be asked to do the voiceover for the £55million film's soundtrack.

"I couldn't believe it," said Mrs Preece, who also had a walk-on part in the film. "When I was playing Carlotta in the stage show a few years ago there was talk of a film then. I joked about giving my back teeth to be in it but never thought it would happen. Doing the voiceover was the next best thing though - I was like a child in a sweet shop.

"I had a wonderful time. It was great fun working with Minnie. She is launching a solo career as a folk singer but she is not an opera singer and doesn't pretend to be."

Miss Driver embarked on her music career in September after winning a £ 1million deal with EMI. Her album, Everything I've Got In My Pocket, reached number 44 in the charts. She is planning a nationwide tour next year.

A spokesman for the film said: "Because her character is a real diva we needed an opera singer to sing those parts. Minnie is a talented singer but the part called for an operatic voice."

Miss Driver, who based her interpretation of the role on Maria Callas, said of the musical demands: "I could only fake it to a point. I could sing the low stuff, but the high? Forget about it.

"It was like glass breaking and dogs start howling when you are singing up there."

Filmgoers interested in hearing what she really sounds like should not leave the cinema too quickly. She is heard singing as the credits roll.

- Daily Mail

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Sierradaddy

Colm Wilkinson would've been a good choice for the Phantom also. He did the Toronto play. I'm really excited about this movie. The trailers look strong, and I've always loved the music. Can't wait til DVD. I definitely won't be seeing it in the theatres, though. I've already gone out to see the play. It'll make a great addition to the DVD collection.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Flutterbywingz

Colm Wilkinson most definitely would have been a better choice!

I can't wait to see the movie.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

Nothing can compare to Michael Crawford's Phantom. Saw it in NY and have the Cd. Good Gracious his voice is the sweetest sound this side of Heaven

IMO I think I wil go put the Cd on now.

Oh I can't wait for the Movie, hope we are not disappointed.
So many times they screw up the movie, fingers crossed XXXX

D

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Flutterbywingz

Michael Crawford does have the sweetest voice!

I hope they don't mess the movie up. So many have attempted to make musicals into movies, but I'm usually disappointed that they use screen actors rather than actual musical theater performers. I heard a while ago that they didn't want to go with Broadway legends, such as Crawford, Wilkinson or Sarah Brightman because they've aged. I think most fans would be willing to overlook their maturity just to see them on film in the roles they originated on Broadway or London's west end.

I was very sad to see The Phantom close in Toronto. It had a good, long run.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

Aged? Michael; Crawford? I wouldn't care if they had to wheel him in from the nursing home so long as the voice was there. No one IMO can takeover for him.

I may not go and see the show, Now I am depressed. Michael; Crawford Old? WHA!!!WHA!!!!1

D

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Sierradaddy

Michael Crawford is the same guy who used to star in a british comedy where his tagline was, "I'm waiting, for Betty...", isn't he?

I think the show was called, Some Mothers Do 'ave 'Em.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

I found this and he did star in that Brit Show Sierra. Lets figure his age and remember I am real senaitve about him and Rod Stewart. Hee Hee

Emerging onto the British show-business scene as a boy soprano, Michael Crawford sang in the choir of St. Paul's Cathedral. Though he made a fleeting film appearance in 1950, Crawford would not become a full-fledged professional until dropping out of high school at age 15. His first important film assignment was the 1958 kiddie-matinee programmer Soap Box Derby. He enjoyed a flurry of film activity in the mid- to late '60s, playing such singing roles as Hero in A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to the Forum (1966) and Cornelius Hackel in Hello, Dolly! (1969). The best of his non-musical film appearances during this period was as the fatally ineffectual Goodman in How I Won the War (1967). His British TV-series assignments have included Sir Francis Drake (1962), Some Mothers Do Have 'Em (1974-1979), and Chalk and Cheese (1979). A familiar presence in West End theatrical productions from 1965, Crawford made his musical comedy bow as star of the London production of Barnum!. In 1988, he won a Tony award for his portrayal of the title character in Andrew Lloyd Webber's Phantom of the Opera. Michael Crawford has since performed the score of Phantom, along with selections from other Lloyd Webber hits, as a solo concert artist. ~ Hal Erickson, All Movie Guide

D. If he made a fleeting appearance in 1950 and he was a "child " that would make him around 57. tHATS OK. But if he was grown up Uh UH.
Last I saw he was singing The Musiiic of The NIght and he wears a mask. so what difference does it make? We never get to see him really unless he is made up withthe sacrs.

Ilove the music so much.maybe I coul dkeep my eyes shut.
D

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Flutterbywingz

It makes no difference to me! Some men become better looking with age. Michael Crawford is one of them!

And his voice is ageless!

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Sierradaddy

To me his voice will always be making the statement, "I'm waiting, for Betty..." Can't help it. The very mention of his NAME sends that quote through my head.

Anyways, back to the movie... I can't wait. I like the girl playing the lead. The lead characters name is Christine, right? I saw that play in '90. Damned if I remember any character's name, but I seem to be able to recall many of the songs, in part or in whole.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

I have the tape or CD I will look and see,cause I am like you S, Only remember Phantom and Christine.

Be back in a sec

D

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

My Cd doesn't list characters but here is original cast:

The Phantom of the Opera (Original 1986 London Cast) [ORIGINAL RECORDING REMASTERED]
Sarah Brightman, Charles Hart, Steve Barton, Richard Stilgoe, The Phantom Of The Opera (Related Recordings), Andrew Lloyd Webber, Michael Crawford
nOW WE KNOW AS MUCH AS WHEN WE STARTED.
Phooey.
D

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Flutterbywingz

I can't resist a good musical!

I'm going to see it on opening night. I'll just have to pretend that the lead's voice isn't annoying!

Reply To this Message

Posted by: schmiggens

It's getting good reviews:

quote:
Opulent 'Phantom' thrills in high style

http://www.journalnow.com/servlet/Satellite?blobcol=urlmainpicture&blobheader=image/jpeg&blobkey=id&blobtable=MGImage&blobwhere=1031779819095&ssbinary=true

For legions of Phantom of the Opera fans (phans?) the world over, the wait is over - and the wait will have been worth it.

Director Joel Schumacher's adaptation of this Andrew Lloyd Webber stage smash has finally come to the big screen. This version of Phantom is as faithful an adaptation to the stage play as we're ever likely to see. That alone should ensure its success at the box office, given the popularity of the play.

Schumacher and a crack team of designers have filled the screen with sumptuous, rich visuals that tend to dwarf the story. And why not? Schumacher has made a spectacle out of a simple storyline much in the same high fashion as Webber did with the stage production. Gaston Leroux's original story is barely a cut above a penny-dreadful potboiler, which is why so many previous screen incarnations differ from each other beyond the initial concept and setting. This presentation is what Phantom fans want - the stage play hasn't become a cultural phenomenon for nothing - and Schumacher and Webber give it to them.

Much as with every other facet of the production, the performances tend to be dwarfed by the sheer opulence of the endeavor. Then again, The Phantom of the Opera - both on stage and now on screen - is chiefly concerned with The Big Picture. Every single element is an end to even larger means.

Gerard Butler plays The Phantom. Emmy Rossum plays The Girl. Patrick Wilson plays The Hero. They make an attractive love triangle, but are merely figures in a much grander landscape.

Again, for Phantom fans, that's how it should be.

This version favors the romantic aspects of the story over the thrilling ones, which previous versions have generally emphasized. The Phantom is a masked, disfigured musical genius who haunts the Paris Opera House. Christine (Rossum) is an orphaned ingenue with whom the Phantom is smitten, and Raoul (Wilson) is the dashing young opera patron who also finds himself drawn to Christine.

Spirited comic relief is provided by Minnie Driver as resident diva La Carlotta, and by Ciaran Hinds and Simon Callow as the new owners of the opera house, initially unperturbed by the Phantom's threats until he begins making good on them. Miranda Richardson plays ballet mistress Madame Giry, and gorgeous Jennifer Ellison plays her daughter (and Christine's best friend), Meg.

The Phantom's obsession with Christine grows as she becomes the toast of Paris - an instant star of the stage. But when Christine begins to reciprocate Raoul's affections, the Phantom makes his displeasure known, leading to a fiery climax whose momentum is sometimes interrupted by the principals' bursting into song. The transition from stage to screen - and the adherence to maintaining as much of the stage production in a screen format - is sometimes a bumpy one, but Schumacher and Webber never look back. This is how they wanted Phantom; take it or leave it.

Schumacher - a filmmaker who has always favored style over substance, sometimes to the point of aggravation - has found the ideal format in which his methodology enhances, rather than detracts from, the overall effect of the work. This is undoubtedly Schumacher's finest hour, and he gets major assists from cinematographer John Mathieson, production designer Anthony Pratt and costume designer Alexandra Byrne - all of whom may well find themselves in the running come Oscar night.


Cool!
Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

Our Local paper had a two page preview in color on Phantom. WOW!!!

Can't wait,bet he lines will be terrible. Cold weather has hit New Or.eans, Crummy thing to happ;en in December.Hee Hee.

All. in ALL it appears that Andrew L Webber is very very pleased.nHMMM

Still would like to hear Michael Crawford, and he is not too old. Its Hollywood itis.
Don''t even have a leading lady to really sing lip Singh ,Hey Schmmiggens, we could do it. Augh but you know Beautiful women don't photograph well remember? Ha Ha.

Merry Christmas friends.

Delta

Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

quote:
Delta said this in post #23 :
Our Local paper had a two page preview in color on Phantom. WOW!!!

Can't wait,bet he lines will be terrible. Cold weather has hit New Or.eans, Crummy thing to happ;en in December.Hee Hee.

All. in ALL it appears that Andrew L Webber is very very pleased.nHMMM

Still would like to hear Michael Crawford, and he is not too old. Its Hollywood itis.
Don''t even have a leading lady to really sing lip Singh ,Hey Schmmiggens, we could do it. Augh but you know Beautiful women don't photograph well remember? Ha Ha.

Merry Christmas friends.

Delta


Hello Delta - Long time no see! Merry Christmas!

I saw the movie yesterday. Got my ticket online and was probably the first one in the theater for the very first showing. I loved it!

I am the world's biggest "Michael Crawford for the Phantom role" fan there ever was, but I was very pleased with Gerard Butler's portrayal and voice. Everyone else, I thought was fabulous.

I can't wait to see the film again soon, as well as my sixth viewing of the stage production when it arrives here in Arizona next June.
.
Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

HI, been a while, soon we will be idoling.

HOpe you guys have a wonderful Christmas.

Glad to hear the Movie was soo good, you were smart to go on line.

I will have to wait to find some simple minded guy to get the idea to take me.

Hmmm I have a date tonight, Maybe he would like to seeit. Hmm

MICHAEL CRAWFORD FOR PRESIDENT

Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

quote:
Delta said this in post #25 :

Hmmm I have a date tonight, Maybe he would like to seeit. Hmm

Be sure to take some kleenex along.

quote:
MICHAEL CRAWFORD FOR PRESIDENT

As you might guess, you'll have no problem convincing me on that one!
Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

quote:
the Phantom makes his displeasure known, leading to a fiery climax whose momentum is sometimes interrupted by the principals' bursting into song. The transition from stage to screen - and the adherence to maintaining as much of the stage production in a screen format - is sometimes a bumpy one, but Schumacher and Webber never look back. This is how they wanted Phantom; take it or leave it.


This is the aspect of this film that gets to me! There are any number of people on other message boards who complain about the characters singing their lines vs. speaking them. One reviewer said something to the effect that it cracked him up in a scene where a noose was around Raoul's neck and, yet, he and the Phantom were singing. He suggested that the time would have been better spent if he tried to break free of the rope. To that, I say, "Duhhh! It's a musical, not a Western!" People who don't care for musicals should NOT bother to go see this movie. They should also avoid "South Pacific", "Camelot", "Oklahoma", "West Side Story". "The Sound of Music" (and on & on & on).

I can tell you this. If you like musicals and never saw POTO before, it's highly unlikely you will not enjoy this movie. If you have previously seen the stage production (which I have, five times) and loved the show, you will be in seventh heaven watching this movie.

If you don't especially care for musicals, do yourself a favor. Stay home! It annoys me when I see how many folks that fit into this category went to see the movie (probably just to accommodate a friend or relative), then complained about how long the movie was, or how they couldn't wait for it to end. For me, I would have liked to stay and see it one more time, but I'll just be patient for another few weeks or so (maybe sooner).

Maybe it's because I'm an admitted "Phantom Phreak", but I was one of only a handful of people who remained in the theater while the closing credits were rolling to hear Andrew Lloyd Webber's new song "Learn To Be Lonely", sung by Minnie Driver, as well as every note of an instrumental medley of music from the movie, which followed that song.

I was a little upset when I read a year ago that there was going to be new music added for the movie version. It concerned me that they might just be spoiling it, but I gotta tell you. It's a beautiful song and well sung by Minnie-a fitting conclusion to a masterpiece of a movie!
.
Reply To this Message

Posted by: schmiggens

quote:
Delta said this in post #23 :
Our Local paper had a two page preview in color on Phantom. WOW!!!


Me too!
Reply To this Message

Posted by: scott_peterson

- this movie looks really good. the trailor was excellent!

Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

... to the theater to see POTO for the second time today. This will be followed by a third viewing within the next few weeks and a sixth viewing of the stage production in June.

On a scale of 1 to 10, this movie rates an 11 in my book.

Oh, and pardon the bad pun in the title (assuming you're familiar with the musical score).
.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

I wonder when people go to the theatre to see an Opera, do they expect the players to talk it?
MAYBE IN POTO they think its a mystery.? Hee Hee

In my opinion thses types should stay home or go watch the Fockers and be entertained like Idiots,. ( sorry the humor in that show is too broad for my liking)

Well one thing is clear, I am wiped out today so will chill and watch old movies.

Take care all.
D

Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

quote:
Delta said this in post #31 :
I wonder when people go to the theatre to see an Opera, do they expect the players to talk it?
MAYBE IN POTO they think its a mystery.? Hee Hee

In my opinion thses types should stay home or go watch the Fockers and be entertained like Idiots,. ( sorry the humor in that show is too broad for my liking)

Well one thing is clear, I am wiped out today so will chill and watch old movies.

Take care all.
D


I guess not everyone shares our mature tastes, Delta.

.
Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

Yes friend sad but true. We are so mature I hate it.

When everything you say is right, there has to be something wrong. Ha Ha.

D

Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

quote:
Delta said this in post #33 :
When everything you say is right, there has to be something wrong.


So true.

BTW, how are things going for you healthwise? Good, I hope.
.
Reply To this Message

Posted by: Lawless

This romantic musical epic is about a mysterious masked figure, Erik (Butler), who roams the undergrounds of 19th century Paris, centering his activity around (or under) the Opera Populaire, where he tutors a beautiful young soprano, Christine (Rossum), who goes on to upstage the city's most famous opera singer, Carlotta (Driver). The Phantom thinks he's found love, until Christine's childhood boyfriend, Vicomte de Chagny (Wilson) shows up.
Release Date: December 22nd, 2004 (limited release).
MPAA Rating: PG-13 for brief violent images.
Distributor: Warner Bros.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

quote:
Delta said this in post #46 :
Thanx AZ I did do it and it was very flattering. Intend to buy the CD as I moan over the lack of Michael Crawfords voice. HEE HEE


Delta, I gotta tell you something I'm sure you don't know. If you search through the Imdb Phantom of the Opera forum, especially in the first couple of months after the movie was released (January & February), you will see that women & girls all around the world were and are swooning & mooning over Gerry Butler, to the point of ad nauseum. The producers purposely selected someone young like him to play the Phantom for that very reason (the box office). I was exctremely upset that they didn't go with Michael Crawford, as you were, because he still sang the music better than anyone alive, and what does his age matter since he's behind a mask anyway? However, the gals who saw the movie (even the MC lovers) didn't stop oohing & aahing over Gerry, many to the point where, if it were a live stage production, would have thrown their keys & undergarments on the stage. I kid you not.

I only mention this because, seeing how you love B.B. on AI, I can only imagine what you would think if you saw the POTO movie, assuming you're anything like the hundreds of women who posted on that board.

.
Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

quote:
AZIdolfan said this in post #35 :


Delta, I gotta tell you something I'm sure you don't know. If you search through the Imdb Phantom of the Opera forum, especially in the first couple of months after the movie was released (January & February), you will see that women & girls all around the world were and are swooning & mooning over Gerry Butler, to the point of ad nauseum. The producers purposely selected someone young like him to play the Phantom for that very reason (the box office). I was exctremely upset that they didn't go with Michael Crawford, as you were, because he still sang the music better than anyone alive, and what does his age matter since he's behind a mask anyway? However, the gals who saw the movie (even the MC lovers) didn't stop oohing & aahing over Gerry, many to the point where, if it were a live stage production, would have thrown their keys & undergarments on the stage. I kid you not.



I am sold so I am going to Amazon and buy the DVD now.

Thanx for the descriptive critique,however I don't think my undergarments will ever leave this great body for anyone, Ha Ha.
D

I only mention this because, seeing how you love B.B. on AI, I can only imagine what you would think if you saw the POTO movie, assuming you're anything like the hundreds of women who posted on that board.

One has nothing to do with the other.
D

.
Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

I went to Amazon and bought Phanthom won't be in until first week in May so while there I also got Shall we Dance with Richard Gere and that J somebody.

And I bought Michael Bublea the Canadian singers Cd. If you would give me a private email in a pm to me I will forward this Crooners songs to you. Theway it is sent them to me, but after Iheard him sing I just had to have his Cd.

Let me know, cause if youlike Sinatra and Nat King Cole you should really dig this new young man from Canada.

D

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Delta

IN fact I am going to go see if I can find Michael Crawfords POTO, I couldn't on Amazon. Strange they only have this Gerry( what guy spells Jerry with a G,no offense hee hee)

Do you know where I can find it?

D

Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

quote:
Delta said this in post #38 :
IN fact I am going to go see if I can find Michael Crawfords POTO, I couldn't on Amazon. Strange they only have this Gerry( what guy spells Jerry with a G,no offense hee hee)

Do you know where I can find it?

D



See PM.

.
Reply To this Message

Posted by: Flutterbywingz

I found the movie to be very disappointing. The only real talent I saw was the person who played Christine. Listening to the guy who played the phantom was like absolute torture. I couldn't wait for the movie to end. I will treasure my memories of seeing the musical live on stage.

It's a shame that the actress who played Christine had to be cast alongside the others in this film. She is the movie's only redeeming quality. Of course, that's just my opinion.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: AZIdolfan

quote:
the_way_it_is said this in post #40 :
I found the movie to be very disappointing. The only real talent I saw was the person who played Christine. Listening to the guy who played the phantom was like absolute torture. I couldn't wait for the movie to end. I will treasure my memories of seeing the musical live on stage.

It's a shame that the actress who played Christine had to be cast alongside the others in this film. She is the movie's only redeeming quality. Of course, that's just my opinion.


And, of course, you're entitled to your opinion and your tastes, as are we all. That's what makes the world go 'round.

Coincidentally, I just saw the stage version of the show for the sixth time yesterday. It had a different cast than the ones I saw previously, years ago, but quite enjoyable, nonetheless. I would probably give my right arm to have seen Michael Crawford & Sarah Brightman do it, but I thoroughly enjoyed every one I've seen.

Counting DVD viewings, I have probably seen the movie version about twelve times. There's nothing like it on the big silver screen though. I am enjoying it more every time I see it and I find all of the performances well done. Naturally, Emmy Rossum stole the show, but I think the others all did very credible jobs and made the film really enjoyable for me. If you couldn't wait for it to end, you were either having a very bad day or else you're not really a died-in-the-wool Phantom Phreak, like me.

FWIW, I have a number of friends and relatives who saw the movie and they all raved about it. A couple of them told me that they really didn't have a good grasp of what the story was about, having seen the show once or twice, until they saw the movie. Yesterday, a woman in the audience, who was sitting next to us, told us that she enjoyed the movie more than the show. That makes at least four different people who told me that. So, again, I say that it's all a matter of taste and opinion. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

.
Reply To this Message

Posted by: Flutterbywingz

Of course, you're right, AZIdolfan.

The Phantom, although I enjoy the musical, has never been on my list of favourite musicals. I am too much of a critic when it comes to making movies out of musicals. I am almost always disappointed when I see that the movie is nothing in comparison to what is captured on live stage.

I would have gone to see it again and again, but it closed its decade long run in Toronto a couple of years ago. I hope it won't stay away too long. And Sarah brightman and Michael Crawford; I would have given my right arm to see them, too.

The people I know who have seen the movie have conflicting opinions on it. Some people, like die hard Phantom Phreaks, think I'm crazy for hating it, but some people are right there with me. It is absolutely a matter of personal taste and opinion.

Being a die hard Les Miserables Freak, I'm sure if they made a movie out of the actual musical, I would find many things to love about it, simply because it's my favourite.

You've seen it six times on stage? I would definitely say you have more of a love for the Phantom than I ever will.

Reply To this Message

Posted by: White Tiger

The Phantom of the opera is my favorite musical and the Phantom is one of my favorite characters of all time, it is also one of the worlds favorite musicals, but what is it that makes the Phantom as loved as it is?

Reply To this Message

Posted by: Sierradaddy

To be honest, I just liked the music, and that's saying a LOT because generally you can't GET me to see a play. I usually can't stand the theatre. It's just not my thing.

I'll go see Showboat, Cats, and I've already seen the Phantom. But I don't know if I'd bother to see any others. Even with the way Hollywood actors seem to be trying to show their "credibility" by headlining in plays on Broadway, basically stealing roles away from strictly-stage actors...

Maybe the play's allure is because it can be frightening, and that's an interesting exploration for a stage play?

Reply To this Message

Pages:  1 Free Forums    Chat Forum

Movies Forum: The Phantom Of The Opera

Forum Forum Forum