Dementors

Book 5: HP & the Order of the Phoenix Forum

I read something somewhere (forgot where) that there is a therory that the Dementors were never under Ministry control, ever. Here's my proof so far.

1. Tried to kiss an innocent person, but, this innocent person just happened to be Harry, the boy who sent Volemort away. (and don't say that it is because he tried a Patronus on them, then Lupin would have no soul.)

2. In OOTP, those 9 Death Eaters got out. Isn't it supposed to make you go crazy, having Dementors near you. Do you think the Dementors did try to harm them and let them go?

Thats it so far, but I'll keep looking.

Good point about the 9 prisioners. They should have been crazy after all those years. I think they were given special treatment by the dementors.

Wow! That's a really good point.

They probably knew that Voldemort would come back, so they were biding their time.

dementors creep me out one way or another but your right it doesn't seem like they were ever under ministry control