Who's your favorite?

American Idol: Season 3 Forum

Who's your favorite american idol contestant out of the 3

Clay Aiken is my favorite

clay duh look at my name

out of the three seasons? or out of the three winners and runner ups? my favorite overall is Michael Keown. But if I had to choose my favorite out of the three winners and runner ups, then I would choose Clay

I have two favorites Clay and Kelly. Clay is my personal favorite because I love his voice....but I think that Kelly is by far the best singer they have ever had on the show

season 1: kelly
season 2: ruben and clay
season 3: Jasmine and Diana

Season 1: Justin
Season2: Clay
Season 3: George

season 1: Kelly Clarkson w/Rj helton being my favorite guy

season 2: Clay Aiken

Season 3: John Stevens, JPL and Diana

Hey ppl i have not seen fantasia's name ANYWHERE!!!!!!!!

1=Kelly Clarkston
2=Ruben Studdard
3=Fantasia Barrino
Overall i like FANTASIA BARRINO!!!!!!!!!!!!

I think Kelly was the best over all!!!!

1-Kelly
2-Clay
3-LaToya

over all favorite-DUH Clay!

well see I love Clay for like ever...but I think Kelly just has a very powerful voice.....

Season 1: Kelly and Justin
Season 2: Clay and Josh
Season 3: John , La Toya and Diana

man Johnstevensgal, we like just about the same people ever season almost.....

My Fav idol of all time is and forever will be DIANA DEGARMO

I so love her, when I was on the web once I heard a song that dissed her and I'm still bothered by it. Dreams is like her best song. Who agrees?

man I am happy to finally meet someone who likes Diana as much as I do....I was starting to think that I was the only one on here, that really liked Diana....she ROCKZ!!!!!

Jon Peter Lewis(JPL) is my faviorite American Idol EVER!! Hes SOO HOOTT and HE can sing soo good

Yall have no idea who rocks....JPL rocks!! He can out sing Diana or Fantasia anyday..plus he looks way beter

JPL was good but his voice isn't as good as Diana's but on looks yea...he has her beat....

huh!!!i think jasmine will always be the best...though she lost the final 3 she still remained humble and she accepted all her frustrations. she's only 17 yet she can sing very well. the final 12 are all good but she excelled very much. jasmine i love you and i'll support you all the way. hope you can go here in the philippines cause lots of filipinos are waiting for you.i love you so much!!!

Yeah if George wasn't picked...Jasmine was my second pick. She just had a much better attitude than Fantasia and Diana. I still can't believe Fantasia won.

Jasmine was good to a point. She'll get a CD deal

it's funny Latoya just got signed the other week...John Stevens already made his cd...he got signed before her