Which was your favorite performance on the AI3 cd?

American Idol: Season 3 Forum

Which was your favorite performance on the AI3 cd?

I am a huge Fantasia fan but if I had to pick a favorite from the cd I would have to say it was Amy Adams' "You Make Me Feel Brand New". She has an amazing voice with great control and she did an amazing job with this song. I have listened to it more than any other on the disc.

I'm a really big fan of John stevens and JPL...but I would have to say that my favorite song is "Ain't no Mountain High Enough" but as far as them singing alone...I like Matt's....Geroge's is up there too...John Stevens is alright...but my favorite out of them is Matt's.

1. Camile
2. Diana
3. La Toya
4. Leah
5. Fantasia
6. George
7. Amy
8. John S
9. Jasmine
10. Jennifer
11. JPL
12. Matt

I think that Matt, Diana, La Toya, George, John, and Amy all did amazing on the cd, but I thought that Matt was the most improved.

if I had to put them in order....this is how it would go.....

1)Matt
2)George
3)John Stevens
4)JPL
5)Diana
6)Jasmine
7)Amy
8)Camile
9)Leah
10)Fantasia
11)Latoya
12)Jennifer Hudson (never listened to her song....)

but I love listening to ain't no mountain high enough

true

i thought that Diana's and Matt's were the best , then George (i just didnt like his song) but i Diana and Matt's were the best by far

George's and Matt's are really good

yeah, i just didnt like the song that George chose. i think he would have done a better job if he sang "aint no mountain high enough" Matts song choice was phenomenal(sp?) and so was Diana's John Stevens' was good too................. i liked alot of people this year but i definatly had my favorites Diana Matt George and LaToya

I liked George's song...I thought it find him kinda

what do you mean?

I thought his voice sounded so good...it's fun singing along with that....."I'm like Me and Mrs. Jones..." everyone thinks I'm nuts when I sing that...but I like singing with his voice....Matt's is awesome and I love singing when goes "I left my home in Georgia".....

omg, I love that part of the song also!

For Matt that is!

1. La Toya
2. Matt
3. George
4. Diana
5. Amy
6. John
7. Fantasia
8. Jennifer
9. Jasmine
10. Leah
11. Jon Peter
12. Camile

yea I love when he says that....

That is the order I think from the best to the worst on the cd this season.

i love singin along to Matts "sittin on the dock of the bay" it is sooooooo funny cause i cant sing worth crud

You just said that you were a good singer, I'm confused.

wen did i say that?

lol yall are always arguing

ain't yall?

who? claysgurl and I?

yeah that's who she meant and we do fight all the time, yet we still luv each other!

Please get back on topic.

sry

clays #1 fan what did we do wrong?

i dont think we did any thing, did we?

I don't know....



I'm dealing with a broken heart, see you all monday

a broken heart? why whats wrong?

I left it in the other places but what happen is that my best friend (who I am so in love with) got a girlfriend and it kinda broke my heart

My favorite tracks on the ai3 cd were fantasia, latoya, jennifer, amy, and george.

honorable mentions go out to leah.

I have only listened to Fantasia once...and that is just because my CD started without me knowing....I have never listened to Latoya or Jennifer's....

I love George's.....I didn't like his voice but for when he sung on BIG BAND NIGHT...but I love him on that song

the cd is overall good. I thought i wasnt going to like it, but i was wrong.

I still like season 1's better....this seasons was alright but they are a few songs I can't stand....but when I was going to the dome thing for Diana when they were doing the finale....well....I made my brother play her song over and over again...and we rolled down the windows and we were pimping Diana's song...it was funny....but anything for the hometown girl!!!!

1. John/Diana(big fan of both of them)
2.Leah/La Toya
3 JPL
4.Jennifer
5.Camille
6.Jasmine
7.Amy
8.Matt
9.George(never listened to his song)
10.Fantasia(never listened to her song)

I said mine on page one but I think that I am going to relist them here....here we go....

1)Matt/Diana
2)John Stevens
3)JPL
4)George
5)Jasmine
6)Amy
7)Leah
8)Camlie
9)Latoya
10)Fantasia
11) Jennifer (still never listened to her song)

I'd have to say JPL's song...somethin about his voice brings me to the edge of my seat!

JPL's song is good but I like the song he sung on tour better. The first one he did. Then I loved when he did..."hey ya"