Ai4, who would you like to see back?

American Idol: Season 3 Forum

Now that AI3 is over, it's time to prepare for AI4. Is anyone on this board planning to audition? I would, but I don't feel like being the next William Hung or being called the worst singer in the world by Simon Also, you know how any previous contestant who didn't make the top 32 can come back and audition as long as they are still within the age limits? Who from the previous Idol seasons would you like to see come back? You all know my first choice...Michael Keown. Also I would like to see Cassie Lebeau (just needs to conquer those nerves), and maybe Lauren Ensweiler, and Scooter Girl. Also maybe Rodrigo Cortes...the guy who sang a really good version of "Isn't She Lovely" during the original auditions, but didn't make it to Hollywood because he said that if he wins, he would donate most of the money to charity. Howabout you guys? Who are your choices?

Good question....

I really would like to see Keown come back...I still thought he got robbed BIG TIME...To choose the Roman brothers over him? The very thought of that makes me laugh! (not funny ha ha...but funny pathetic ha ha).

Id like to see Lisa try again, and definitely Nicole Tieri..(sp?)

Actually...this girl might not win or make it on, but Id like to see Army girl back...I still thought she did okay enough to try again.

Lisa Leushner was really good..however, she made the top 32, so she won't be able to audition again =(. Hopefully she'll get a record deal on her own now. And as for Army Girl Martha, yea, I thought she was at least good enough to make it to Hollywood. Hopefully she'll come back, be a little less flashy, and be able to make it farther second time around.

yea I thought Army girl should of gone to Hollywood she wasn't the best but she was good

I want to see Amy Adams and Lisa Lueschner back. It would be Lisa's third year. And I hope that Amy will try again as well. She's got an amazing voice.

Amy can't try out again. Once you make it to the top 12 you can't try out again

I want to see Michael Keown again and Nicole Tierry(sp).

I had NO idea that you couldn't try out again if you made the top 32. That SUCKS... in my humble opinion!

I don't know if it once you make it to the top 32 but I know once you make it to the top 12...you can't

well I heard you can't try out again if you made the top 32. It sucks for those contestants who made the top 32 but not the top 12. But in a way I think it's fair. the top 32 already got a lot of exposure and it would be a disadvantage for other people.

well I agree that once you make it into the top 32 you shouldn't be able to try-out again because then every year you would have the same people back over and over again

i'd have to say i'd definitely like to see cassie labeau back.

They really blew it when they would not let her sing. She was awesome.

I that wildcard show this year really lost AI some credibility. Next season, they better let everyone they call back sing again.

I will be auditioning next year.

i hope they let everyone sing in the wildcard show next year. i cant even imagine how much that broke thier hearts when they werent asked to sing after being called back.

Advance I am going to audition for ai4 too!

I'm trying out for AI4.....

I don't like how they let the judges pick any of the wildcards...that should be our job...we should pick the last 4...not the judges pick 3 and we only pick one......I didn't mind this year because my JPL got through but I didn't like any of the judges pick (but maybe George)

I also don't like how they told the others right on TV that they couldn't sing....they should of done that before the show started.....

I hope American Idol gets it's stuff together before next year

are you really trying out??? Are you going to the Georgia Auditions?

To believe it or not they are not coming to Gerogia this time around....(ok winner this year and both runner-up's from the last two years...tried out in Ga)...so my mom is going to drive with me down to Orlando to try-out

omg are you serious! NO GEORGIA! wtf! I heard they might do a NC one but I doubt it

you know what would be sooooooooooo funny? if that Edger(sp?) guy came back again !

dude Idol should go to NC because if you ask me...that is the where all the good singers seem to be coming from....

yeah seriously! i mean clay and now fantasia! im not old enough to auditionfor the show but if i was i would audition every one says i should!

they should go to NC...

How old are you....I know it sucks that they are moving the age up to 18.....I don't think that is right....I just passed the age limit for next year

Clays #1 fan does have a good voice, you should hear us sing together, we sound awesome!!!!!

man, to bad ya'all can't try out....

I don't think he was robbed! Simon was just not looking for someone superficial and fake! he wants someone real and american voted for fantasia just cuz she's a mom and was wakko enough to name her baby zion!

Ryan Seacrest said they are moving up the age. It was on one of them TV shows like ET, Extra or Accress Hollywood. They said they want an older crowd next year so I believe that done is done....

who wasn't robbed????

what do you think we'll expect to see for next season? I'm expecting to see a lot of Elvis impersonators since one of the audition ciities is Vegas hehehe. And based on how each season, there is someone with pink hair go through, I'm expecting another pink hair with a good voice. And I'm also expecting at least one person to be singing Unchained Melody. How about you guys?

I agree with you on the thing of Pink hair...someone with pink hair is going to make it...someone always does....also someone always sings Unchained Melody...and vegas is going to have some funny people trying out....I'm going to Orlando to try-out...I'm upset that they are not having one in Georgia this year....