The Fight Game

J.R.R. Tolkien Forum

We have one in the LOTR forum, but this is for any character ever created by Tolkien.
I'll start off

Feanor vs Sauron

feanor he is the strongest willed an arguably the greatest of elve.Thingol vs. Meadhros

ooh..thats a tough one. I'd have to say Meadhros. he seemed to have the gift of speech his father did, and a will to match.

Manwe vs. Ulmo

Manwe, because he is the most powerful of Valar.

Finrod Felagund vs. Fingon.

Finrod

Fingolfin vs Finrod Felagund

Fingolfin,


Gothmog vs. Glaurung

Gothmog

Gothmog vs Sauron

Gothmog.

Glaurung vs. Ancalagon

Ancalagon. He can fly, Glaurung can't

Gothmog vs Ecthelion (Elf who dies in the Fall of Gondolin.)

Ecthelion because he killed Gothmog in the book anyway.

Glorfindel vs. Ecthelion

Ecthelion (killing the Lord of Balrogs is no small feat)

Gothmog vs Squishy

Gothmog.

Turin Turambur vs. Beren Camlost

Beren

Turin Turambur vs Aragorn Ellasar

Turin Turambur

Meadhros vs. Elrond

Meadhros

Feanor vs Melkor

Melkor

Finarfin vs. Fingolfin

Fingolfin

Fingolfin and Finarfin vs Feanor

Feanor

Ungoliant vs. Gothmog

Ungoliant

Shelob vs Gothmog

Gothmog

Smaug vs. Gothmog

It'd probably be a tie. Dragon fire wouldn't hurt a balrog, and they are both physically strong


Ungoliant vs Melkor.

Ungoliant because Morgoth had to be rescued by his Balrogs when Ungoliant tryed to take the silmarills.

The Ents vs. the stone giants from the hobbit

The ents

The ents vs. the ringwraiths

The Ents

Numenor vs. Noldor

Noldor

Elves vs Dwarves

Elves I suppose, but I think dwarves would put up a rather tough fight

Trolls vs. balrogs

Balrogs

Trolls vs dwarves

Trolls because they are bigger and stronger.

Eagles vs. Dragons

Dragons

Trolls vs. the spiders of Mirkwood

Trolls

Shelob vs Ungoliant

Ungoliant

Ungoliant vs. Beorn

Ungoliant

Beorn vs Ents

the Ents. Beorn vs. Lurtz

uh...Lurtz! The Ents of course!

Lurtz vs Ugluk

Ugluk, he was in the book as well and Lurtz wasn't.

Isldur vs. Anarion

Isildur

Elendil vs Isildur

Elendil.

Gil Galad vs. Elrond

Gil-Galad

Gil-Galad vs. Galadriel

Galadriel

Beren vs. Aragorn

Beren

Turin vs Hurin

Hurin

J.R.R Tolkien vs. Peter Jackson

Tolkien

Amandil vs Earendil

Earendil

Cirion of Gondor vs. Eorl the young

Eorl the Young

Theoden vs Denethor

Now that's an interesting one to think about...But I'll go for Theodon

Smaug vs. all nine ringwraiths

Smaug

All the ents vs Glaurung

It depends on where it was. If the battle was by a river the Ents but anywhere else and Glaurung would win.

Olwe vs. Finwe

Is anyone out there?!

Finwe

Tulkas vs Manwe

Manwe.

Tulkas vs. Mandos

Tulkas

Melkor vs Tulkas

Tulkas.

Mandos vs. Melkor

Melkor

Hurin vs Turin

Hurin

Eldarion vs. Faramir

hmmm...Faramir

Thorin Oakenshield vs Dain Ironfoot

Dain Ironfoot.

Thorin Oakenshield vs. Thorin Stonehelm

Thorin Oakenshield

Durin I vs Thorin Oakenshield

Durin the deathless.

Durin the deathless vs Gimli Elf-friend

Durin the Deathless

Thorin Oakenshield vs Thrain

Thorin Oakenshield

Dain Ironfoot vs Durin the deathless

Durin the Deathless

Beorn vs gandalf the grey

Beorn.

Tom Bombadil vs. Melkor

Melkor

Bombadil vs Sauron

Bombadil

Bombadil vs Gandalf

bombadil

Saruman vs Bombadil

Bombadil

Gandalf vs. Orome

Orome

Gandalf vs Melian

Gandalf.

Beren Camlost vs. Bard the Bowman

Beren

Eomer vs Theoden

I'd go for Theoden.

Orome vs Beren Camlost