who should be in final 4?

American Idol: Season 3 Forum

So I missed tonight's show but agreed that the bottom 3 this week (along with Jasmine) should not be in the final 4.

In my opinion, Diana is an emotionless stage-mom product, John Stevens is a child trying in vain to fill a man's shoes, and Jasmine is a wanna-be Barbie princess. The other 4 are legitimate performers with exquisite voices, who actually FEEL what they are singing, which is the only way to make it real for us, the audience.

Now, it may be noted that my choice of final four are all black people, so I feel the need to mention that I am not black, thought Clay was the best last season, and feel it is the age/life experience difference, not their color, that makes them stand out against the others.

i know they got voted out but jpl matt john stevens and thats it for me but thats who i wanted to get in the finel 3

Diana, John Stevens, and Jasmine. That's it. I love them and I don't care what other people say. They are the REAL GOOD singers.

just so i dont have to type out all their names...definitely it should be all the BLACK people.

i think, as j butter b put it, all the BLACK people deserve to be in the top 4... but i don't really like fantasia's voice, or latoya, and i don't care either way about Jennifer, althought i know that all 3 of them are very good. I do however, LOVE george huff, and I hope he's in the top 4. heck, i hoep he wins the thing. i don't really like AI3 as much as AI2. the people this year arent as good.

i dont think ne one can compare to clay..sry off topic..but i say george...NOT JOHN..any one but...i figure latoya and fantasia are...but i dont really care for either..i know what your saying..they are good..but i wouldnt go out and buy thier cd...haha..not that i would even buy any cd..i cant believe i JUst now...bought clays cd...

i agree with all of u.. i love george.. i want him to win but i think more ppl like fantasia out of everyone.. she will prolly win it all..

[COLOR=deeppink]I really hope George gets in, he's the best of all males, well theres not much left though lol, but I think fantasia, latoya will make it and hopefully george. and maybe jasmine, based on who everyone likes and how good they sing.

4. Jennifer Hudson
3. La Toya London
2. George Huff
1. Fantasia Barrino

I am voting for John but who knows how far he will go. I think Diana should go this week and then Jasmine and then so on.

GO JS

I reckon the top four will be:

4.Jennifer, 3. Latoya, 2.George, 1.Fantasia

Fantasia's last performance was absolutely top notch and it has shown that she has a good range in songs that she can sing. George was improving up til last week and has stuttered when trying to slow down the tempo ... Latoya is always at the same standard and not unique enough or charismatic enough to surpass the previous 2 and Jennifer is improving but the other 2 girls are upping their performances too....

The top 4 are definitely standing out above the others now and it will be interesting to see how they battle it out to the end...

Diana and John S should be going in the next 2 weeks in that order i expect and Jasmine seems like she will be 5th.

But thats just my opinion :-)

1. La Toya London
2. Diana Degarmo
3. George Huff
4. Jennifer Hudson

John stevens go always...I hope you go far...and go far behind Idol

lol..@marisan...why are you telling ME this....I really dont care ....I cant believe you actually took the time to paste my post, and then type that ignorant message behind it....I dont care what race you are or what singers you like..or who you think looks nice...LOL...I was just saying who will be in the top 4 like asked...You cant be serious....(LOL for the next 15 minutes) :lol ok....im cool now...i bet you dont even look nice yourself or sound good judging that your fav contestant was one of the worst on the show....HAHAHAHAHA ...

NO FLAMING! We do not allow personal attacks on other members. Keep it clean.

InReview Staff

I have one thing to say to John Stevens, "Believe in yourself and other people will believe in you too." Just remember that and you WILL go far!

Ok, this may just be because I am young and don't know fully about the ways of the world but....I like John Stevens because he is a nice cute guy who has a voice and he has to have guts to get up there week after week and sing his heart out and get bad marks from Simon. I hope John goes far and if you have watched him on the show or in the videos they show, he is starting to come out of his shell a little....I'm going to keep voting till Ryan says he is gone..GO JS

This year...I only like maybe a few...well mostly John Stevens and then JPl....last year...just had a group of really good singers like Clay, Ruben, Kimberly and some others.....and then even season one had it's good singers but I think that by now...people want to be on AI because it makes you a star...I mean look at william hung??? he can't sing but his album is selling!!!!

Oh, don't even get me started on the atrocity that is William Hung.

It's rediculous how they're playing it up. That poor kid probably doesn't even know how horrible he is. He's just a moneymaker, no real talent.

I work at Wal-Mart, and he even has a commercial on the Wal-Mart TV Network. "Hi Wal-Mart shoppers! I'm William Hung!" with his horrid dancing.

OMG you work at wal*mart, so does my mom...my point though....people want to be on idol because they want their 15 minutes of fame...but then again I am going to try my luck for AI4, but GO JS

1. fantasia barrino
2. la toya london
3. jennifer hudson
4. toss-up between diana de garmo and camille velasco and jasmine trias

all you fantasia haters obviously know nothing about what a great marketing voice is all about. fyi: fantasia does not need this hokey/fixed racist bent FOX trash to get where she's going - to the top. she has a definite niche: blues, jazz, soul, r&b. watch out macy gray and co ...

la toya too has a great future ahead of her, as does jennifer hudson.

this format, where artists are required to sing songs of former stars - way out of their realm or voice range is disingenuous at best.

ryan seacrest is becoming more and more of a joke with each passing week.

it's about time FOX is exposed for their trashy programming and american idol for being the embarrasing farce it really is. randy and paula need to withdraw from next year's american idol - maybe try and join star search where the calibre of singing is truly worthy ... and recognised for fulfilling their title. in star search, arsinio hall too is pathetic - lost his funniness - years ago ...


lest the silver lining fades ... disappears altogether; become not complacent - dwell not upon the negativiity; but harness the dreams & ideals; break into unknown territory - discover ... and grow ...

judging someone along the narrow stereotypes of colour or creed or gender; is the aberration of an insecure person ... disrespect for one's fellow being ...

I truly think that it is going to come down to Diana and Latoya in the top 2.......I don't agree nor disagree....I don't really care anymore because I liked John Stevens!!! I just hope them all well and everything...

I'm a John Fan through and through, and no one will ever conpair

if i had to chose 1 person it would be me!

U????

I want to try out next year but at my school, now that the school right down the road got Diana there...our school wants to get someone to go to AI....and our chorus teacher will even help you get ready for the big day if you want...so who knows...maybe I'll try out!!!!

1. La Toya
2.Diana
3.Jennifer
4. John

the top 4 should of been...

1)Diana
2)Latoya
3)George
4)Fantasia

I love John and all but I'm sorry he wasn't so good to be in the top 4....

My favorite contestants are:

4. Leah LaBelle
3. Jasmine Trias
2. Camile Velasco
1. Diana DeGarmo

these girls are all hot they all should have been in the top 4 and maybe Amy too she was good

NO NO NO I SHOULD HAVE BEEN IN THE TOP FOR GOOD THING PEOPLE DON'T KNOW WHO I AM I COULD BE BRAD PITT YOU NEVER KNOW

my favorites were John Stevens and JPL and I thought Diana could have it....

oh and hey WYvelascoNH...what does your name mean?