Which of the finalists who have been CUT deserved it

American Idol: Season 3 Forum

ok so far were down to 8 contestants. these have all been said to atleast have some kind of voice, though im not sure about some of them....well so far leah,matt,amy and camile have been elimated. did they all deserve it? should they have lasted longer than they did? post your thoughts

Welcome to the forum localgirl.

Leah's voice was not strong enough. Camille was so off key during the Elton John night. Amy, I just do not get why she was cut. She has a fantastic voice.

i think that amy wasnt original enough, her voice was to much like any other singer. its true that leahs voice wasnt strong enough. matthew just didnt have what it took. camile had a differnt unique voice, but her song choice ended the road for her. out of those four, i see camile being the only with a future in the music business. i wish her the best of luck because i see that she has the potential to do very very well.

I know you're a big Camille fan and I'm a big fan of R&B, but this isn't R&B idol (I wish it was). This is a pop thing.

The people who deserved to get cut were Camille and Leah Labelle and that's it!

in agreement that Amy did not deserve to be cut...

Amy has a beautiful voice, and I figured that JPL, Camille, and John Stevens would be gone before she was eliminated. Now....JPL is a big favorite, but I honestly don' t think he's got a strong enough voice. I didn't think that Camille would make it as far as she did, and when she was eliminated I got a lil tear in my eye as well. I truely felt for her, even though I felt it was her time to be cut.

amy didnt have enough going for her. she was already at the top of her game and it just wasnt enough to keep her in the competition.

yeah i agree.. i love JPL but i think half the reason that he is still in it is bc he has a bunch of little girls voting him through.. bc i truly think that amy had a better vioce than him

of all the ones cut so far, camile was the only one i was glad to see go. she just didn't seem to be improving at all.