| Posted by: xtinas#1fan | | This american idol winner has a good voice but not all the looks as Christina has. Kelly could have a good carear if she would just let Christina help her with all of her songs. Like she did with miss indapendant. Witch was a good song but it would of sold more and done better if Xtina would of song it... | | Reply To this Message
|
| Posted by: claymybuttercup | | ha haha you need to go some where far away b cuz you bashed clay and now kelly back off whos next the ugly garden tool christina??!! ha ha ha ha ha | | Reply To this Message
|
| Posted by: PhantomStallion | | I still can't believe you even said that about Clay xtinas#1fan!
He is ssooo awsome!!!!! And so is Kelly! | | Reply To this Message
|
| Posted by: ClayFan4ever | | they are both awesome and I don't know even why you are putting her stuff in the Clay Aiken forum. This forum is for Clay fans ONLY and I don't care if you don't like Clay but I do and the rest of us do too and I like Kelly too so I think that you need to go on somewhere because your act is getting real old real fast!!! | | Reply To this Message
|
| Posted by: cLayAiKeN313 | | how about we dont give him the satisfaction..and dont respond..or maybe even look at his threads..cause this isnt going any where...youre lucky no kelly fans go here...its so lonesome..there is like only a few threads...but they would be just as mad..I am not complaining about christina..cause she has always had a really good voice, but why dont you try listening to clay...go to mnclayfans.com and go to the top right..choose a tour city and watch ONE..thats all i ask and then try posting.. | | Reply To this Message
|
| Posted by: schmiggens | |
| quote: |
| This forum is for Clay fans ONLY |
Actually all forums are for anyone who has anything to say about the subject. Not just for posting niceness. xtina's#1fan has not posted anything that is overly nasty or mean, he is just stating his opinion.
I am not closing or deleting any posts or threads just based on the fact that Clay fans don't like xtina's#1fan's opinion.
| | Reply To this Message
|
| Posted by: schmiggens | |
| quote: |
xtinas#1fan said this in post #1 :
This american idol winner has a good voice but not all the looks as Christina has. Kelly could have a good carear if she would just let Christina help her with all of her songs. Like she did with miss indapendant. Witch was a good song but it would of sold more and done better if Xtina would of song it... |
I think Kelly is good looking. Just in a different way to Christina, Kelly has a more wholesome look about her.
I think Kelly can have a good career as she is already, I don't thihnk she needs to try and ride on anyone's coat tails the way you imply that she is doing to Christina. Sure Christina wrote that one song, but big deal?
People write songs for other people all the time and sometimes they sell well, sometimes they don't. I think the singer is not what makes the song, but the song itself and Miss Independant was good song and probably would have done well even if Madonna or Ashanti or anyone had sung it.
| | Reply To this Message
|
| Posted by: clayfan101 | | hahahahahahahaha
xtinas#1fan, have you gone to the avril lavigne, hilary duff, faith hill, ruben studdard, britney spears, and madonna forums yet? I'm sure they could all be compared to Christina as well. 
It's hard to compare Kelly with Christina, they are very different. Kelly is more of a PG person... and she doesnt USUALLY wear underwear as clothing. Or wear too much fake tan stuff. | | Reply To this Message
|
| Posted by: ~*W*~ | | Kelly is very talented! She's just very conservative.. She is beautiful, She just doesn't look like everyone else. I love her, And her voice is amazing. | | Reply To this Message
|
| Posted by: Clays#1 fan | | i think that now Christina has changed her image (again) she is alot better in my eyes, I'm not trying to juge her but she looked scary and ugly b4. i no this forum isnt for niceness but you can chill xtinas#1. | | Reply To this Message
|
| Posted by: ~*W*~ | | Hmm.. I don't think she was ugly.. No matter what she does to her hair she'll always be beautiful.. But it wasn't one of her greatest looks. I think she looks way better as a blonde.. | | Reply To this Message
|
Kelly Clarkson Forum: Xtina Wanna Be
|
