The 'This or That' game....LOTR style!

Lord of the Rings Trilogy Forum

Ring of Barahir.

Elrond's tiara or Morgoth's crown?

M.

Tiara

Speak Elvish or the black speech?

Elvish, although it would be cool to know the black speech too. I would get along well with the Nazgul and Sauron.

Sword or staff?

M.

Sword. Raaaah!

Have elf hair or hobbit hair?

Elf hair. Smooooooth.

Arwen or Luthien?

M.

Luthien, don't know why!

Frodo or Pippin?

Although I think both act very stupid sometimes, but I would go with Frodo. He makes less mistakes.

Fell beast or mumakil?

M.

Fell beast.

Be a guard of the citadel, or an esquire of Rohan?

esquire of rohan!

Where would you rather live Rohan or Rivendell?

Rivendell. More comfortable.

Minas Ithil or Minas Morgul?

M.

Minas Morgul

Mount Doom or Minas Morgul?

Minas Ithil and Minas Morgul are the same, just different names under different rulers.

Minas Morgul. More spooky.

Boromir or Faramir?

M.

Faramir

Denethor or Saruman? (and you have to choose )

Saruman. Atleast he has some brain.

Aragorn or Legolas?

M.

Haha, true Adi

Thats an easy one for me after all Aragorn's my favorie character So Aragorn it is

Frodo or Sam? Seems like I have asked this one before...Oh well

Sam, although Frodo isn't bad too.

Moria or Mordor?

M.

Mordor, no idea why..

Shelob or Squ...the Balrog

Balrog. Atleast I can use him for my barbeque.

Cave troll or mountain troll?

M.

Your too funny Adi

Mountain troll...Don't think I've ever heard of a mountain troll in Lotr, but sounds better then cave troll

Let's see, be chased by a balrog...or shelob?

Balrog. Atleast I would stay warm from all the heat.

Lembas bread or taters?

M.

Taters!

The White city or the Golden Hall?

White city. Bigger and better.

Argonath or weathertop?

M.

Weathertop

Rohan or Gondor?

Rohan, I prefer blondes...

Sam's soil, or Gimli's hair?

Sam's soil

Go to Mordor yourself, or let someone else do the job?

tobacco or ale? (being hobbits favorite vice)

Benyamin, you have to answer the last question asked and then you can ask another question

I'll answer his anyway....you cant beat a good mug of ale!!!

Elves from Imladris or Elves from Lorien?

Lorien, gotta love Cate Blanchett

Imladris or Rivendell?

Imladris - sounds better!

Gandalf or Mithrandir?

oooooh! Erm!!!! Umm.......Ernil i Pheriannath! Sounds bette, and i like the meaning!

Samwise the Brave or Samwise Gamgee?

Samwise the Brave

Samwise or Hamfast ('Half-wit' or 'stay-at-home')?

Samwise!

The Hobbits in the Books or in the Films?

Frodo and Merry in the book, Pippin and Sam in the film

Gamgee or Gardner?

Gardner

Go to Mordor yourself or let someone else do the job?

Go myself!! And you would have to tie me up in a sack to stop me.

Legolas: Annoying or Hot?

Guess...

Eorl or Helm?

Eorl

You see a mass of Urak Hai, chasing you down...Sprint...or Attack?

Ataaaaaaaaack!!!!!! (only because i couldnt run fast enough to outrun them!!!)

Meriadoc the Magnificent or Mater Holdwine?

Meriadoc the Magnificent

Samwise the Brave or Samwise the Gardener?

Samwise the Brave

Brace o' conies or same old lembas bread?

Brace o' coonies!

Taters or fish, raw and wrrrrriggggling?

PO-TAT-OES, Lovely big golden chips, even you couldn't say no to that!

Numenoreans or Dunedain?

Numenoreans.

Haradrim or Black numenoreans?

M.

Black numenoreans I suppose

Think Frodo is annoying or a great ringbearer?

Annoying. No self-control. Whines too much.

Lembas bread or elvish cloaks?

M.

elvish cloaks

which is better lotr books or movies?

Never finished the books completely, the writing is not my style... so I would say movies.

Have messy hobbit hair or smooth silken elvish hair?

M.

for me? smooth silken elvish hair, I do love the hobbit hair though, don't get me wrong

Live in a hobbit hole or Rivendell?

Rivendell. Hobbit holes are too small.

Shire or Bree?

MM.

Shire

LOTR: One book, three books, or six books?

3 books

Dwarves or elves?

I'm gonna answer my own question to keep this thread from dying

Dwarves

Shire or Rivendell?

Rivendell. Elf women are hot, er, I mean cool.

Legolas or Haldir? (Both of them have swollen heads )

M.

Swollen heads But legolas for this one I guess

Aragorn or Faramir?

Faramir. I like his character better

Boromir or Faramir

Faramir....I always felt sorry for him

If you had to choose..Would you live in Mordor or Shelob's Lair?

Mordor. Better chance of survival. Plus the orcs would make me feel at home. With Shelob there would be no one to talk to.

Wormtongue or Denethor?

M.

Denathor, he had a reason for being crazy.

Uruks or Uruk Hai?

Uruk-hai. Atleast they can travel in sunlight.

Which is cooler: Barad-dur or Orthanc?

M.

Barad-Dur

Minas Tirith or Minas Morgul?

Minas Tirith. Minas Morgul is cool too with its green walls.

Ringwraith no. 1 or Ringwraith no. 5?

M.

no. 5 Adi

Ringwraiths or balrogs?

Balrogs. Atleast you can see them even if they are not wearing any clothes.

Morgoth or Sauron?

M.

Morgoth

Trolls or Orcs?

Orcs

Helm's Deep or Pelannor Fields?

Pelannor fields...mmm...carnage...I mean..uh

Balrogs or Dragons

Balrogs.

Aragorn singing or Pippin singing?

ohh thats a tough one, as much as I love Aragorn (after all he is my favorite character ) He's better when he's taking an an army of urak hai...but Pippin just about made me cry during his song...So Pippin

Who makes you laugh more...Pippin or Gimli?

Pippin

Who would you trust more, a Brandybuck or a Took??

Probably a Brandybuck

Arwen's or Eowyn's style?

Éowyn, got to dig the whole, warrior chick style!!!

Who do you wish would join InReview, Pippin or Legolas?

Pippin....Wouldnt that be fun!!!

What about Aragorn or Gimli on InReview?

Aragorn

Who would you liek to sit down and watch the Trilogy with...Billy Boyd or Sean Bean?

Billy Boyd, of course

Who would you like to meet, Viggo Mortensen or Billy Boyd?

Billy Boyd, because he's less intimidating.



Who had better costumes, Liv or Miranda?

Tough one but Miranda

Sean Beans or Viggo's costumes?

Viggo's in ROTK

Book or Film?

Book as always

Sam or Merry?

Tough one!

I'll have to say Sam!



Cinema or DVD?

Cinema

Fellowship of the Ring or Two Towers?

Fellowship

Orlando or Viggo?

You should know this one Pip....Viggo!!!!!! hehe

Who freaked you out the most, Shelob or the Witch King?